Speaking of musical genres, I’m not sure whether Gordon Lightfoot was
held back by their boundaries or transcended them – I prefer to think the
latter. Although his earliest material had a decidedly country sound (and his
later “Sundown” actually hit #13 on Billboard’s Hot Country Singles chart), he
first gained attention as a folk artist, with performers such as Peter, Paul &
Mary recording some of his material. Because of that background, I was always
surprised when I found his albums in stores filed under Pop/Rock rather than in
the Folk section. Similarly, I could never quite understand why he didn’t get
nearly as much attention as did others (Jackson Browne, James Taylor, Carole
King, fellow Canadian Joni Mitchell) during the 1970s “singer-songwriter” craze.
Was it because he didn’t live in or hang around L.A.? Was it because his music
leaned more “adult contemporary” than rock? (Although JT was certainly never
known for rocking out.) Maybe it was because his songs never felt all that
introspective: allmusic.com refers to typical singer-songwriter lyrics of the
era that “were personal, although … often veiled by layers of metaphors and
obscure imagery.”
All that aside, I’ve always had this somewhat fanciful notion that
there’s some supernatural power that assigns all of us some fixed number of
great songs. (For most of us, of course, that number is zero.) During his prime
years during the 1960s and 1970s, Gordon Lightfoot certainly came up with far
more than his share.
Favorite songs:
The Way I Feel (version from the album of the same name)
The Last Time I Saw Her
The Circle Is Small
Early Morning Rain
Summer Side Of Life
Did She Mention My Name
If You Could Read My Mind
10 Degrees & Getting Colder
Song For A Winter's Night
For Lovin' Me
Crossroads
Softly
Same Old Loverman
Endless Wire
Pussywillows, Cat-Tails
Sundown
Can't Depend On Love
Sit Down Young Stranger
That Same Old Obsession
So I remember one day in the Lower East Side of Funkhouser, you asked Brent Gardner what he thought of LIghtfoot's newest song, Sundown, and he said he thought Lightfoot sounded off-key.
ReplyDeleteYou flipped him the bird and left the room.
Well, obviously I knew that, in 2019, I'd be naming him one of my all-time favorites. (Lightfoot that is, not Brent.) Although Brent will always have a place in my heart for introducing us to The Boss. (BTW, "Blinded By The Light" is great!)
DeleteAmen on both counts re: Brent.
Delete